Hideya Shintani1, Tomoya Shintani2,3,*, Masashi Sato4
1Department of Internal Medicine, Osaka Saiseikai Izuo Hospital, Osaka, 551-0032, Japan
2Graduate School of Agricultural Science, Ehime University, Matsuyama, 790-8577, Japan
3Department of Nutritional Representative - Supplement Adviser, The Japanese Clinical Nutrition Association, Tokyo, 153-0044, Japan
4Faculty of Agriculture, Kagawa University, Kagawa, 761-0701, Japan
*Corresponding Author: Tomoya Shintani, Graduate School of Agricultural Science, Ehime University, Matsuyama 790-8577, Japan; Department of Nutritional Representative - Supplement Adviser, The Japanese Clinical Nutrition Association, Tokyo, 153-0044, Japan
Received: 15 July 2020; Accepted: 30 July 2020; Published: 11 August 2020
Abstract
Although cord blood is important in human development, its functions are not well understood. Cord blood shows high potential for use in research studies aimed at maintaining a healthy, long life, as it contains various functional components such as anticancer agents against leukemia. Recently, D-Allose, a stereoisomer of D-glucose, was found in human umbilical cord blood and sera of women. D-Allose has been shown to have anti-cancer activity, reduce reperfusion damage, and have anti-metabolic syndrome effects. Previously, Chen et al. reviewed the production and function of D-Allose but did not discuss its potential as a medical drug based on its presence in women’s serum, its safety in humans, its GMP manufacturing, its efficacy in liver injury, its influence on animal lifespan, the biological activity of its derivatives, or its applicability as a diagnostic reagent. In this review, we cite new references and describe the above points of D-Allose and its potential for pharmaceutical applications.
D-Allose (D-All); Serum component; Medicinal plants; Reperfusion damage prevention; Anti-cancer; Anti-metabolic syndrome effects
D-Allose (D-All)articles, Serum component articles, Medicinal plants articles, Reperfusion damage prevention articles, Anti-cancer articles, Anti-metabolic syndrome effects articles
Cord blood is critical in development, but is not well understood [1,2]. Some components of maternal and cord blood have been reported to protect against oxidative toxicity in the blood [3]. Additionally, multipotent stem cells can be isolated from umbilical cord blood [4]. Cord blood shows wide potential for research on maintaining a healthy, long life because of its anti-disease and anticancer properties. Recently, D-All (Figure 1) was detected in human umbilical cord blood [5]. D-All, a stereoisomer of D-glucose, is a rare sugar present in limited quantities in nature [6]. It is considered as a "fetal sugar" because it was first found in umbilical cord blood in 2013; its levels are very low in nature [6]. The physiological role of D-All in vivo is unknown, but various physiological functions with pharmaceutical applications have been revealed. Studies of the physiological function of D-All have conventionally focused on its function as an antioxidant that suppresses oxidative stress, which is considered to be the most important function. Previously, Chen et al. reviewed the function of D-All but did not discuss its potential as a medical drug based on its presence in women’s serum, its safety in humans, the possibility of GMP manufacturing, its efficacy in liver injury, its influence on animal lifespan, the biological activity of its derivatives, or its applicability as a diagnostic reagent [7]. They focused instead on the microbial production of D-All and its general physiological activity.
The current review of recent studies discusses D-All in pharmaceutical applications. We also describe the possible involvement of D-All in the regulation of glucose metabolism and of intracellular stress in addition to the points mentioned above.
In 2013, it was reported that vaginal delivery following spontaneous labor leads to higher levels of D-All in umbilical cord blood sera than after elective cesarean section without labor, confirming that D-All is present in the human body [5]. This suggests that infants born via vaginal delivery can produce D-All as protection against ischemia, although this hypothesis requires further detailed investigation.
Metabolomics of celomic fluid, such as pleural effusion and abdominal dropsy, from 41 women revealed D-All in humans [8]. These results were confirmed by serum metabolomic analysis of women by another research group [9]. However, these studies did not examine the physiological significance and metabolic mechanism of D-All in the body. Previous studies [6, 8, 9] investigated specimens of only fetal or female origin. There are no reports of the presence of D-All in men, and thus, future studies involving men are warranted. Nonetheless, D-All has unique characteristics, as described in this review.
No studies have demonstrated the presence of D-All in animals except in fetuses and women. However, at least three types of medicinal herbs, Halodule pinifolia, Tamarindus indica, and Crataeva nurvala, contain free D-All (Figure 2). The Indian seaweed H. pinifolia, which protects against urinary tract infections, was found to contain 3.7% D-All [10]. D-All has also been detected in the aqueous extract of T. indica pulp (2017). T. indica is a plant used in traditional medicine to treat cold, fever, stomach disorders, diarrhea, and jaundice and as a skin cleanser [11]. C. nurvala Buch-Hum is an indigenous herb extensively used in traditional medicine in South Asian countries to treat rheumatic fever, gastric irritation, and constipation [11].
D-All, a stereoisomer of D-glucose, is a C-3 epimer of glucose [13] (Figure 3). Crystalline D-All is available only in the laboratory [14], as Good Manufacturing Practice (GMP)-grade D-All has not been completely established. However, safe manufacturing at the food industrial level has nearly been achieved. D-All can be produced using the Izumoring strategy, which is a systematic method for producing all monosaccharide isomers using microbial enzymes such as L-rhamnose isomerase enzymes and/or immobilized enzymes [15]. Mass production methods developed by Izumori have provided insight into the biological properties of rare sugars [16-17]. D-All is mass produced from D-allulose, which is a structural isomer of D-All, through the action of recombinant L-rhamnose isomerase cross-linked with glutaraldehyde [18]. D-allulose is enzymatically produced from D-fructose, which is a product of glycolysis and isomerization of starch [17]. Further research, optimization, and standardization of food-grade production methods may lead to the establishment of GMP-grade production methods.
The safety of D-All has been established to some extent in preclinical and clinical phase 1 studies. For example, the acute and sub-chronic toxicity of D-All in rats has been investigated. In an acute toxicity test, the calculated LD50 value was reported to be 20.5 g/kg. In a sub-chronic toxicity test (6 months), no abnormal values were found in the serum chemical and hematological test results. These results suggest that D-All is not toxic to rats [19].
No diarrhea or any other abnormality was observed when D-All was administered orally (8 g/kg body weight) to young rats. Urinary and fecal excretion levels of D-All during the 24 h following oral administration were 91% and 3%, respectively. The D-All content in the stomach decreased rapidly over 3 h, with only low levels found in the small intestine and cecum. These results suggest that D-All is largely absorbable from the digestive tract into the blood and is then rapidly excreted through the urine [20]. A phase 1, clinical, randomized, single-blind, crossover study was conducted in healthy subjects to evaluate D-All fermentability in the large intestine, urinary excretion, and carbohydrate energy expenditure [21].
Reactive oxygen species (ROS) are very important in oxidative stress, and a small percentage of oxygen in living organisms exists as ROS [22]. ROS are produced via oxidative phosphorylation in the mitochondrial electron transfer system [23]. Under conditions that promote the generation of ROS through the action of electron transfer system inhibitors, D-glucose and D-All partially suppress the generation of mitochondrial-derived ROS and ATP [24]. This suggests that the mitochondrial respiratory chain competes with D-glucose by binding to mitochondrial respiratory chain molecules rather than by inhibiting D-glucose uptake. The molecular basis for the prevention of hypertension and inhibition of ischemic disorders at the individual level is the inhibitory effect on ROS generation in mitochondria. In rat studies, D-All was shown to attenuate brain damage and induce neuroprotection by reducing oxidative DNA damage caused by ROS [25]. D-glucose contributes to ATP synthesis to promote the production of ROS in neuronal cells. However, D-All suppresses ROS production by competing with D-glucose in the mitochondria, as previously described [26]. The mechanism underlying the therapeutic potential of D-All in brain ischemia/reperfusion injury may involve attenuation of blood-brain barrier disruption and the inflammatory response via PPARγ-dependent regulation of nuclear factor-κB [27]. Additionally, mitogen-activated protein kinase 1, a key regulator of cellular physiology and immune responses, was recently shown to have an alleviative effect on ischemia/reperfusion injury in skin flaps [28]. Because interventional methods for reducing reperfusion injury are limited, further studies of the potential of D-All are needed.
The inhibitory effect of D-All on cancer has been reported by many researchers. Recently, the possible anti-cancer mechanism of D-All was elucidated. Cancer dysregulates cell growth, which requires large amounts of D-glucose as a major energy source [29] and is related to the Warburg effect. Thus, overexpression of some glucose transporters (GLUTs) promotes the transport of glucose into cancer cells. D-All is also involved in thioredoxin-interacting protein (TXNIP)-mediated redox regulation [30], which has been reported to inhibit osteoclast differentiation and cancer cell proliferation [31]. Additionally, TXNIP can downregulate the overexpression of GLUT1 in many cancer cells. Thus, D-All suppresses the proliferation of many cancer cells. Moreover, D-All has been shown to prohibit cancer cells from absorbing glucose [32]. The anti-proliferative mechanism is partially attributed to p27kip1, a marker of the cell cycle transition, where D-All induces TXNIP in vitro [30], which has been confirmed in vivo [33]. Various studies have demonstrated the antitumor effect of D-All using many types of cultured cancer cells.
Interestingly, intracellular TXNIP expression is specifically and markedly enhanced in MOLT-4F cells (T-cell lymphoblastic leukemia) by D-All treatment, and increases in p27kip1, a cell cycle inhibitor, have been observed [34]. To enhance its effectiveness against leukemia, a D-All derivative with anti-proliferative activity against MOLT-4F cells has been developed [35]. In addition, D-All has been reported to suppress a variety of carcinomas, such as cervical and skin [36], ovarian [37], hepatocellular [38], pancreas [39], prostate [40-41], head, neck [42], and lung cancers [43].
Some studies have shown that combined use of D-All with other interventions is more effective than the use of other interventions alone. In particular, some studies have shown that combining D-All with other chemotherapeutic agents has synergistic anti-cancer effects, as will be described below. The antitumor efficacy of 2-deoxyglucose and D-All has been reported to be enhanced by p38 inhibition in pancreatic and ovarian cell lines [39]. D-All facilitates the efficacy of radiation by enhancing apoptosis of cancer cells by inducing TXNIP expression [44]. Combination therapy with D-All and docetaxel was recently shown to be more effective than single therapy with docetaxel [41]. A more recent study investigated the radiosensitizing and chemosensitizing potential of D-All in an in vivo model of head and neck cancer. The results suggest that D-All can enhance the antitumor effects of chemoradiotherapy while sparing normal tissues [45]. Taken together, the evidence suggests that D-All has many potential applications in clinical treatment.
The main physiological effect of D-All is the inhibition of ROS generation by modulating carbohydrate metabolism. Unlike antioxidants with reducing power, such as vitamin C, D-All is characterized by its ability to suppress ROS generation. Recently, D-All was reported to reduce endoplasmic reticulum (ER) stress, which is related to ROS [46]. The effect of D-All on superoxide radicals and ER stress was examined in cultured human coronary artery endothelial cells [47]. ER stress was measured with an ER stress-sensitive secreted protein and by determining the phosphorylation levels of key proteins in the unfolded protein response, namely CHOP47, eIF2α, and JNK1. D-glucose increased ER stress, whereas treatment with D-All reduced superoxide radicals and ER stress in vitro.
Along with reductions in ROS and ER stress or suppression of inflammation, D-All showed the following effects: prevention of hypertension, reduction of kidney damage, inhibition of osteoclast differentiation, and anti-aging effects (Figure 4).
D-All has been reported to suppress the generation of reactive oxygen-producing enzymes and increases in blood pressure [48], because ROS generated from the vascular endothelium contribute to increased blood pressure. A significant decrease in both systolic and diastolic blood pressure was observed in salt-sensitive hypertensive rats raised on a saline diet after administration of 2 g/kg body weight/day of D-All. D-All has a protective effect against ischemic organ damage, such as cerebral infarction and myocardial infarction, which are caused by large amounts of ROS. In addition, D-All is not only a functional food that can inhibit cancer cell and osteoblast proliferation, but also a pharmaceutical and quasi-drug with increasing potential for development.
Cisplatin is a potent antineoplastic agent widely used to treat various forms of cancer. However, its therapeutic use is limited because of its dose-dependent nephrotoxicity. Inflammatory mechanisms may play an important role in the pathogenesis of cisplatin-induced nephrotoxicity, which D-All has been shown to ameliorate in mice [49]. As renal impairment caused by metabolic syndrome is also known to be induced by inflammation, it would be interesting to assess the effect of D-All on renal impairment in future studies.
Anti-aging effects mediated by reduction in D-glucose metabolism have been reported in experiments using nematodes [50]. In a nematode life extension study, Caenorhabditis elegans wild-type N2 and daf-16 (nematode homolog of FOXO1, a transcription factor downstream of the insulin signaling pathway) mutants were used. The mean life span of N2 nematodes treated with D-All (28 mM) was prolonged by approximately 24%. In contrast, no lifespan extension was observed in the daf-16 mutant. These results suggest that D-All-induced prolonged lifespan is mediated by the insulin signaling pathway.
In general, the rate of bone resorption by osteoclasts and bone formation by osteoblasts is balanced to maintain bone strength. In osteoporosis, there is excessive bone breakdown by osteoclasts, and the osteoblasts cannot keep up with bone formation. D-All may prevent osteoporosis by inhibiting osteoclast differentiation in vitro [30].
Nonalcoholic steatohepatitis (NASH) is characterized by excess lipid accumulation and inflammation in hepatocytes. A study aiming to provide insights into the preventive effects of D-All on the onset of NASH suggested that D-All prevents NASH by blocking hepatic lipid accumulation and progressive inflammation. [51]. More recently, the improvement effect of D-All was also reported in a rat model of liver injury, which involved the use of a toxic substance that overproduces active oxygen [52].
Based on its high solubility, it could be presumed that D-All can be used as a syrup, similar to D-glucose. D-All is a zero-caloric sweetener with a sweetness 80% of that of sucrose [53, 54]. D-All, as a sucrose substitute, is an ideal food additive. Moreover, as it is a reducing sugar with an aldehyde group, it can be recruited in the Maillard reaction, which is a chemical reaction between amino acids and reducing sugars that results in improvements in color and taste [55]. In addition, since D-All is a monosaccharide, it exerts an osmotic pressure, which could prevent microbial contamination; this pressure is expected to be higher than that of sugar. Thus, D-All is a promising candidate for applications in medicinal and functional foods.
Applications in medical drugs or medical reagents, in addition to foods, are expected. D-All, as an immunosuppressant, could increase allograft survival [56]. Some studies have found that D-All has a cryoprotective effect on cell survival [57]. D-All could also reduce tissue injury [58] and be used during organ transplantation to decrease tissue damage via its anti-oxidative effects [59].
The antioxidant functions of D-All could make it a therapeutic option for various diseases resulting from oxidative stress. D-All has the potential for clinical application as a pharmaceutical agent, such as in the clinical therapy or prevention of cancer, stroke [60], and hypertension, because of its remarkable physiological functions discussed so far.
D-All has potential therapeutic applications in diseases caused by nematode parasitism. Its effectiveness in these diseases may be due to species differences in the metabolic effects of D-All. The effect of metronidazole on trichomonad parasites was valid for prohibiting the parasite from developing drug resistance [61]. D-All can repress the growth of the nematode Caenorhabditis elegans [62], and the nematocidal activity of newly obtained D-All derivatives against C. elegans larvae has also been reported [63]. Further studies on its applications to ward off parasitic nematodes are required.
The physical properties of D-All are also being investigated to determine their application in clinical diagnosis. To improve noninvasive positron emission tomography investigations, the behavior of labeled D-All derivatives in organs was examined [64]. In a basic assessment of its stability in such application, high-performance liquid chromatography analysis showed no decomposition of the compound even after up to 6 h in rabbit blood plasma [64]. The diagnostic properties of novel fluorine-18-labeled D-All were also tested [65]. Further research on D-All will lead to a promising future for applications of D-All and its derivatives as medical drugs or medical reagents.
There are many reports on the oxidative stress-reducing effect of D-All [7]. Higher amounts of D-All have been detected in fetal umbilical cord in spontaneously delivered fetuses than in fetuses born via cesarean section. These results suggest that D-All may reduce oxidative stress at birth in humans, although further studies need to be conducted to determine its functions in detail.
Inhibition of cancer cell proliferation could be the most important physiological effect of D-All. In general, cancer mortality has been found to be lower in women than in men [66], but the reason for this is unknown. The fact that D-All and its anticancer and anti-metabolic syndrome effects have been reported only in the blood of women and not of men may support this epidemiological study.
The World Health Organization recommends restricting consumption of sugars to no more than 10% of daily caloric intake, with a proposal to lower this level to 5% or less for optimal health [67]. Naturally occurring d-All is an attractive alternative sweetener. The results of animal studies have indicated a utilizable energy value of approximately zero, and safety tests for future functional sweeteners have already been completed.
A systematic review of the anticancer effect of TXNIP inducer was conducted to summarize the potential of thioredoxin system inhibitors for cancer treatment [68]. Because D-All is a trace component of serum and circulates throughout the body in the bloodstream, it may be effective against systemic cancers. The effect of D-All on the thioredoxin system may be very promising for clinical cancer therapy in the future. However, while the research available on the anti-cancer effect of D-All is being examined, discussions on the mechanism of action and relevance of involvement of D-All in cancer are rare and are not included in this review. The studies and evidence presented in this review, such as those based on in vitro experiments, were in preliminary stages, and the conclusions derived are speculative. Further research is necessary to more accurately describe mechanisms and applications of D-All in cancer treatment.
D-All, a stereoisomer of D-glucose, is a rare sugar present in limited quantities in nature. D-All has been detected at low levels in human cord blood and in medicinal herbs. However, it is challenging to study D-All owing to its low abundance. D-All could be produced by the Izumoring strategy, which is a systematic method for the production of all monosaccharide isomers using microbial enzymes. The mass production methods developed by Izumori have provided insights into its biological properties. The safety of D-All has been established in rats and in clinical studies, and its utilizable energy value is approximately zero. Studies have demonstrated various functions of D-All, such as anti-tumor activity, anti-hypertension effects, and brain protection from ischemic injury (Figure 5). These functions mainly result from the suppression of ROS generation via competition for D-glucose utilization. Based on its beneficial health effects, D-All is expected to be a potent anti-metabolic syndrome drug and pharmaceutical precursor. These beneficial properties make it a suitable candidate for medicinal foods or functional foods.
This study was partially supported by the Sasakawa Scientific Research Grant from The Japan Science Society [2018-6021].
We thank Ken Izumori (Kagawa University, Kagawa, Japan), Masaaki Tokuda (Kagawa University, Kagawa, Japan), and the late Kazuhiro Okuma (Matsutani Chemical Industry Co., Ltd., Hyogo, Japan) for their valuable advice.
The authors declare no conflicts of interest. Tomoya Shintani is an employee of Matsutani Chemical Industry Co., Ltd. (Hyogo, Japan), which manufactures and sells sugar and carbohydrate products. However, the company provided no financial support for this study. This manuscript was written as joint research while Tomoya Shintani was at Ehime University.